She walked away before Amazon HR could deliver a game-changing update
Amazon just scored a clean win in a discrimination case – and the ruling has major takeaways for HR teams managing performance improvement plans (PIPs).
A federal judge in North Carolina dismissed all claims brought by a former Amazon manager who alleged race, color, and age discrimination, retaliation, harassment, and FMLA retaliation after receiving the company's lowest performance rating and being placed on a performance improvement plan. The decision was handed down on March 11, 2026 by United States District Judge Terrence W. Boyle.
Cynthia Anderson, an African-American woman over 40, joined Amazon in May 2019 as a manager in the customer service department of the grocery business line. Her role centered on coordinating and driving productivity for a contact center team. Following an internal restructuring in early 2020, her team was folded into the shipping and delivery support unit.
Anderson received feedback through weekly one-on-ones, occasional skip-level meetings, and a written year-end review. Her 2020 review landed her a "least effective" rating – the lowest mark on Amazon's performance scale at the time. On February 2, 2021, she was placed on a PIP, a 30- to 60-day structured coaching period designed to help employees improve.
After the PIP started, Anderson raised concerns about disparate treatment, prompting Amazon to launch an internal investigation. Days later, on February 8, 2021, she...
exporters knowingly avoided U. S. duties on Asian and European flat-rolled steel products, agreeing to pay $19 million to resolve the dispute, according to a press release issued Wednesday by the U...