One remark, a long paper trail – and why context decided everything
One firefighter, one offensive remark after George Floyd's murder, and a termination an Ohio court refused to overturn.
An Ohio appeals court has upheld the firing of a Columbus firefighter who, days after George Floyd was murdered, told colleagues over a dispatch call to stand on someone's neck and wait. The remark, made in a room that included an African American co-worker, capped a disciplinary record the court found more than justified termination.
The ruling, handed down May 28, 2026, by the Tenth Appellate District, is worth a few minutes for anyone who runs an HR function. It answers a question that comes up in disciplinary meetings all the time: can one comment end a career, and how much does the rest of an employee's history count?
Robin Garrison had been a firefighter for the City of Columbus since 1997. On May 31, 2020, after a call asking how long until law enforcement would arrive, he made the comment in the Fire Alarm Office. Elizabeth Finnegan, an African American colleague, testified she was shocked and appalled. Garrison apologized to the room afterward and agreed a written counseling form was appropriate.
That apology did not save him, and the comment was not his only problem. An earlier investigation found that Garrison made comments to a female firefighter, Jennifer Wilkinson, that the city's EEO investigator concluded were inappropriate and sexually harassing, and that he retaliated...
Welcome to Reality Check, NewsGuard’s nonpartisan newsletter that tracks the false claims and conspiracy theories that shape our world — and who’s behind them. Please support us by becoming a premi...