Two owners earned tens of millions - the fine print still caught them
A federal appeals court has ruled that two high-earning insurance producers breached their contracts by resigning overnight and moving to a rival firm.
The Eighth Circuit's August 26 decision reversed several trial-court rulings that had favored the pair, former producer members of Lockton, a Missouri-based insurance brokerage. Both quit in 2022, declared their memberships terminated "effective immediately," and joined competitor Alliant.
The court read Lockton's operating agreement to mean what it said. Producers "may be terminated" on 30 days' written notice - and the court held that was the only way out, not one option among several. By leaving immediately and joining a rival before their interests ended, the two breached both the notice rule and the fiduciary duties they owed as members. That reversed the trial court, which had treated the notice as optional.
These were owners, not ordinary staff. Over 15 years, one producer earned roughly $15.7 million and the other about $14.3 million in profit distributions. The court leaned on that ownership status, noting California - where both lived and worked - is far less hostile to competitive restrictions tied to business owners than to those binding rank-and-file employees.
That distinction mattered because the whole fight was about which state's law applied. Lockton had lobbied Missouri's legislature to make its restrictive covenants "more friendly and...
RCMP Staff Sgt. Jerry Nutbrown brings you behind the scenes with a series of columns taking you behind police work and how it’s done in our community. If you have a question you think needs to be ...