×
Saturday, October 17, 2026

Lack of transcripts 'prejudices employment hearings' | News | Law Gazette - Law Gazette

More than 300 doctors, journalists and whistleblowers have called for employment tribunal proceedings to be recorded and official transcripts provided to parties to improve fairness and access to justice.

Signatories of a letter sent to Judge Barry Clarke, president of the employment tribunal services in England and Wales, say that an 'accurate and complete court record is a fundamental prerequisite and basis for a fair trial'. But, they argue, the lack of an independent and complete transcript is a 'serious shortcoming' in the system.

At present, no official recording or transcripts are made of proceedings in the employment tribunal, and any person making one faces charges for contempt of court.

Current arrangements, the letter argues, mean that well-resourced defendants who can afford to employ a professional note-taker have a 'considerable advantage' over claimants, who are often representing themselves and rely on 'memory and incomplete notes'.

Judges’ notes are regarded as the official record and are made available to employment appeal tribunals, but they are seen as private documents and are not available to the parties.

If the judgment that follows a hearing omits substantial elements of oral evidence that support the claimant’s case, the prospects of a successful appeal are hampered without a court record.

'This imbalance irretrievably denies parties the right to prepare adequately an appeal and it is manifestly unfair,' the letter states. Reference to the full...



Read Full Story: https://www.lawgazette.co.uk/practice/lack-of-transcripts-prejudices-employme...