Its own data showed just a 14 percent placement rate - and the judges noticed
A federal appeals court told employers that inviting workers into a "reassignment process" is not the same as offering a real accommodation.
On August 21, 2026, the Ninth Circuit reversed part of a lower court's ruling that had dismissed religious discrimination claims from five former Washington Department of Fish & Wildlife employees. The workers had received religious exemptions from a state COVID-19 vaccine mandate in 2021, then were told they could not keep their jobs.
Rather than a concrete offer, the department pointed them to a reassignment process. Its letters said, "Reassignment remains a possibility, although opportunities may be limited." The employees never completed the process, and the department fired them.
The district court sided with the employer, holding that offering the process met its duty under Title VII. The appeals court disagreed.
Under Title VII, once an employee shows a religious conflict, the employer must take the first step and propose an accommodation that removes it - an alternate job or a changed arrangement - while preserving pay and conditions. Only then does the employee have to cooperate. A process, the panel said, is not a proposal.
The numbers did not help the department. Its own data showed that of 122 religious accommodation requests, only 17 were granted - a 14 percent rate. The record said nothing about what those jobs paid or whether they resolved...
A health care provider has agreed to pay $2.4 million to resolve allegations that it violated the False Claims Act by causing the submission of false diagnosis codes to increase payments under the ...