The paperwork all pointed one way - control over the work pointed the other
Paperwork calling a worker an independent contractor didn't hold up. A Pennsylvania court said control over the job is what counts.
A satellite dish installer fell from a ladder on October 28, 2019, and was badly hurt while on a job for J&S Technology Solutions. When he filed for workers' compensation, J&S argued he wasn't an employee at all. He was an independent contractor, the company said, and the paperwork seemed to back that up.
He had signed an independent contractor agreement when J&S first hired him in 2015. He was paid by the job and issued a 1099. He drove his own van, used his own hand tools, and carried his own commercial liability insurance. On his tax forms, he listed himself as a sole proprietor.
None of it settled the question. On August 4, 2026, the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania affirmed that the installer was an employee of J&S when he was injured.
The court leaned on a familiar rule: control over the work, and the right to control it, are the primary factors. What mattered, the court said, was that J&S had the right to control the work, even where it didn't exercise that right. The installer couldn't work for competing companies, couldn't turn down jobs, and couldn't bring a helper without approval. Every customer issue ran through J&S. The company handled his background check, trained him, supplied the major equipment, and tracked him through an app...
[Sportschosun Jang Jong-ho] A total of 34.789 billion won in false National Health Insurance claims was detected at 839 health care institutions over the past four years (2022-2025). According to d...