She frustrated three doctors and drew sanctions - but the justices capped the fallout
The Utah Supreme Court just capped what employers can do when a worker blocks a required medical exam: suspend the claim, never dismiss it.
The decision, filed on July 16, 2026, ends a long fight over three failed medical exams and what an employer can do when a claimant will not cooperate.
The worker filed her claim in 2021, alleging that a 2015 injury to her thumb and elbow led to complex regional pain syndrome, a neurological pain condition. Her employer, Kroger, had a statutory right to send her to an independent medical exam, or IME, with a physician of its choice.
None of the three exams the employer arranged succeeded. The first physician refused to finish, alleging the worker was "very confrontational and very hostile" after learning she could not record the session. A second doctor cancelled before meeting her. A third ended the exam during a dispute over air conditioning, which the worker said aggravated her pain condition.
An administrative law judge suspended the claim and assessed costs. On appeal, the Labor Commission Appeals Board went further and dismissed the claim entirely. It described a "pattern of antagonistic and obstructive behavior" and treated the failed exams as ordinary discovery violations, the kind that let a tribunal dismiss a case under the state's civil procedure rules. It also imposed monetary sanctions on the worker's attorneys.
The Supreme Court reversed...
Baseless claims that former US Secretary of State Henry Kissinger gave a speech on eugenics and forcible vaccinations to the World Health Organisation (WHO) have recirculated online. The posts alle...