Safety audits and on-site reps were not enough to shift liability
A 29-year-old demolition worker died after a catwalk collapsed at a shuttered Pennsylvania power plant.
The worker was employed by North American Dismantling, the contractor hired to tear down the Hatfield’s Ferry Power Station in Carmichaels, Pennsylvania. FirstEnergy had shut down coal generation at the plant in 2013 under Environmental Protection Agency pressure. By the time demolition started in 2022, the facility had been closed nine years. The job meant bringing down cooling towers around 500 feet high and emissions stacks reaching 700-plus feet.
On September 28, 2022, the worker was dismantling a metal catwalk on one of the smokestacks when it failed and collapsed. He fell 40 feet, suffering what the court described as “catastrophic” and “horrifically painful” injuries. He died at a West Virginia hospital. He was 29 and survived by two young children.
His mother filed a wrongful death action in June 2024, arguing FirstEnergy Service, FirstEnergy Corp., and plant owner Allegheny Energy Supply retained enough control over the demolition to owe her son a duty of care. The district court dismissed. On October 14, 2026, the Third Circuit affirmed 2-1.
Two Pennsylvania doctrines did the heavy lifting. The first: when a company hires an independent contractor, it generally owes no duty to that contractor’s workers unless it retains detailed control over how the work is done - not just what gets done. The...
[OSEN=Choi Lee-jung Reporter] As past remarks by singer Yang Hong-won expressing his dislike of infidelity resurface, reactions continue to grow that the recent 'motel infidelity allegations' agai...