The lawyer she sent them to had been disbarred - and it still cost her the job
A doctor who forwarded confidential company emails while fighting her hospital's vaccine mandate has lost her retaliation case against her former employer.
On July 13, 2026, the US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit ruled that the physician did not engage in legally protected activity when she opposed a COVID-19 vaccine policy. Her firing, the court held, broke no employment law.
The doctor worked for St. Elizabeth Physicians (SEP) in Kentucky. In August 2021, the health system told staff to get vaccinated by October 1 or obtain "an exemption for medical or sincerely-held religious reasons." She objected on both scientific and religious grounds. She campaigned against the policy and helped circulate a petition signed by forty-seven medical professionals.
Along the way, she forwarded four internal company emails to a lawyer who was publicly advertising litigation against the hospital and preparing a class action. The court noted that the lawyer had been disbarred at the time, though the doctor said she believed he was a practicing attorney. She was not a party to that litigation, and she said she never asked the firm to represent her.
The timing mattered. She applied for a religious exemption on September 13. SEP granted it on September 17. Then, on October 4, the employer fired her anyway. The termination letter listed "for-cause" reasons: it said she had "misappropriated SEP property" by...
A video is being widely circulated on social media with sensational claims that “Goodbye Islam in Iran,” alleging that over ten tons of Qurans were thrown into a river and more than 50,000 mosques...