The evidence was there. The employer just never asked the judge to use it
An employer had a defense that could sink a workers' comp claim. It never argued the point - and Utah's top court made that count.
The Utah Supreme Court on August 20, 2026 reopened a workers' compensation case after ruling that the employer, Darden Restaurant, gave up a late-notice defense it had raised on paper but never pursued at the hearing.
The claim started in the kitchen. On July 1, 2020, a manager at an Olive Garden in St. George, owned by Darden, slipped on spilled ice while carrying a bucket of it across the floor. He hit his shoulder on the ice machine and his head on the wall, then landed on his back with the bucket on his chest. He took ibuprofen and finished his shift. Shoulder surgery followed a month later. Neck pain surfaced that December.
Much of the case turned on a question familiar to any HR team: what counts as notice that a worker was hurt. Utah gives workers 180 days to report a work injury, and a missed deadline bars the claim. The manager said he told his supervisor within a week - a voicemail the day he fell ("I kinda fell today, kinda hurt my right shoulder. It really hurts."), a follow-up call, and again in person ("My shoulder really hurts. I can't even lift my arm."). His supervisor testified he never reported the accident to her.
Darden had listed the late-notice defense in its answer and pretrial disclosures. But at the hearing it used the missing report to argue...
ST. PAUL, Minn. — Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison filed two civil lawsuits against businesses and individuals accused of defrauding federal child nutrition programs during the COVID-19 pa...