One stipulation may now keep an employee's HR file out of the courtroom in Iowa
Iowa employers just got a powerful new tool to keep messy HR files and past discipline out of negligence trials.
The Iowa Supreme Court ruled on May 22, 2026, that plaintiffs cannot bring a separate negligent hiring, retention, or supervision claim against an employer when there is no dispute that the employee was acting within the scope of employment and the employer is liable for any negligence by that worker.
The unanimous ruling adopts what courts call the preemption rule. It was a question of first impression in Iowa, and the court sided with the position taken by states including California, Colorado, Indiana, Missouri, and Washington, while rejecting the approach in states such as Georgia, Illinois, Kentucky, South Carolina, and Tennessee.
For HR professionals, the practical effect is sharp. Once a company concedes vicarious liability, a plaintiff can no longer run a parallel case picking apart how a worker was hired, retained, or supervised. The court said the second claim becomes redundant, invites prejudicial evidence about a worker's record, and risks double recovery against the same employer.
The case arose from the death of Garrett Baldwin at Iowa Methodist Medical Center. According to the opinion, Baldwin was on continuous dialysis when a nurse on his critical care team fastened the dialysis tubing to his bed rail using a tourniquet or clip that left no slack. When he was...
A British woman who accused a banker of rape in Hong Kong has been jailed for six years for blackmail and perverting the course of public justice. Isabel Rose, a 26-year-old events manager from so...